[He's trying to understand, but he's not sure he's following. Carlisle's world is just so different from his that he's not sure he'll ever be able to fully comprehend it. ]

And there's no way to .. put the pieces back together?

[He assumes not. If it was so simple then Carlisle wouldn't look like he's about to be sick right in front of him.]

So you're saying that when you die, you'll come back to life only it won't really be you?

Jesus, that's fucking horrible.